Vinod's Blog
Random musings from a libertarian, tech geek...
Friday, October 01, 2004 - 07:26 AM Permanent link for Comparing the Wars
Comparing the Wars

Since so much of Kerry's position last night was about how the US was unfairly burdened with 90% of the cost and 90% of the casualties in the war, I thought it would be cool to bring forward this great article by Mark Levin w.r.t. coalition participation in Iraq vs. S. Korea.  I took Mark's numbers, popped 'em into a table & compiled some stats to make the numbers easier to compare -

Korean WarIraq War
Total = 387,570Total = 149,985
# non-US = 39,570# non-US = 23,485
% non-US = 10.2%% non-US = 15.6%
# countries = 15# countries = 32
  • United States: 348,000
  • Great Britain: 14,198
  • Canada: 6,146
  • Turkey: 5,455
  • Australia: 2,282
  • Philippines: 1,496
  • New Zealand: 1,389
  • Thailand: 1,294
  • Ethiopia: 1,271
  • Greece: 1,263
  • France: 1,119
  • Colombia: 1,068
  • Belgium/Luxembourg: 944
  • South Africa: 826
  • Netherlands: 819
  • United States: 126,500
  • Great Britain: 8,300
  • Italy: 3,120
  • Poland: 2,400
  • Ukraine: 1,650
  • Netherlands: 1,400
  • Australia: 850
  • Romania: 800
  • Japan: 600
  • South Korea: 600
  • Denmark: 520
  • Bulgaria: 485
  • Thailand: 450
  • El Salvador: 380
  • Hungary: 300
  • Singapore: 200
  • Norway: 155
  • Azerbaijan: 150
  • Georgia: 150
  • Mongolia: 140
  • Latvia: 120
  • Portugal: 110
  • Czech Republic: 110
  • Lithuania: 105
  • Slovakia: 105
  • Albania: 70
  • New Zealand: 60
  • Tonga: 45
  • Estonia: 40
  • Kazakhstan: 30
  • Macedonia: 30
  • Moldova: 10  

This is surprising on several fronts -

  • The Korean War was, by most international accounts & likely by Kerry's standards, a "Good War" to repel a hostile invading nation & it received full UN sanction.  It was even ostensibly conducted under UN Leadership.
  • Levin's Korean war numbers do NOT  include S. Korean troops.   Now, it's hard to say how you'd use that stat to make a point about foreign participation in the war in either direction.
  • As Levin notes, despite UN sanction and even front-line leadership, France was of minimal support in Korea and Germany non-existant.
  • The differential between US Military capability vs. coalition partners is FAR greater now than it was in Korea - ostensibly, in some ways the coalition needed the additional partners far more in Korea than in Iraq
  • Regardless, the US was still responsible for close to 90% of the manpower (and presumably the casualties) in Korea.
  • Anyone else impressed that Ethiopia sent 1200 troops to fight in Korea?!?!

Permanent link for Comparing the Wars   Comments [ ] :: Main :: Archives